• Home
  • Reviews
  • Interviews
  • Lists
    • Yearly Top Tens
    • Trailers
    • Contact
    • Hire Me
    • About
Menu

World of Reel

Street Address
City, State, Zip
Phone Number
Home
Cristian Mungiu's ‘Fjord' Acquired by Neon for 2026 Release
Capture (1).png
Andy Muschietti to Direct Sci-Fi ‘Drift'
Screenshot 2025-05-12 112348.png
‘Shadow Force': Joe Carnahan's $60M Action Movie Bombs With $2M Opening
Screenshot 2025-04-16 093926.png
‘Megalopolis’ Making-Of Doc ‘Megadoc’ Lands at Utopia
Capture.png
Pixar’s ‘Elio’ Overhauled: Rewrites, Director Swap, and a $300M Budget
Featured
Capture.PNG
Aug 19, 2019
3-Hour ‘Midsommar' Director's Cut Screened in NYC
Aug 19, 2019

This year’s 12th edition of the Scary Movies festival at Film at Lincoln Center premiered Ari Aster’s extended version of “Midsommar” this past Saturday.

Aug 19, 2019

World of Reel

  • Home
  • Reviews
  • Interviews
  • Lists
  • More
    • Yearly Top Tens
    • Trailers
  • About
    • Contact
    • Hire Me
    • About

Guillermo del Toro Loses It After Controversial Essay Calls Scorsese ‘An Uneven Talent’

October 7, 2022 Jordan Ruimy

Of all the filmmakers that one can call overrated, this particular film critic had to choose Martin Scorsese.

Yesterday, Scorsese was the subject of a highly controversial new essay in The Critic, which claims that director is overpraised and, quite frankly, not that talented.

Writer Sean Egan put it this way: “Scorsese has lazily settled on Mafia-Picture Director as a main calling” going on to describe Scorsese as an “uneven talent.”

The article has no doubt caused predictable controversy around the film community, but it severely triggered Guillermo del Toro who took to Twitter on Friday to criticize the essay and defend Scorsese’s cinema.

“I very, very seldom post anything contradictory here,” del Toro wrote, “but the amount of misconceptions, sloppy inaccuracies and hostile adjectives not backed by an actual rationale is offensive, cruel and ill-intentioned. This article baited them traffic, but at what cost?”

He continued: “To be clear: If God offered to shorten my life to lengthen Scorsese’s- I’d take the deal. This man understands Cinema. Defends Cinema. Embodies Cinema. He has always fought for the art of it and against the industry of it. He has never been tamed and has a firm place in history.”

Hey, listen, there are plenty of people out there who don’t like Scorsese’s input from the last 20 years. However, even if you scratch off everything he’s directed these last two decades, you still have a filmography that includes “Taxi Driver,” “Mean Streets,” “Goodfellas,” “The King of Comedy,” “Casino,” “After Hours,” and “Raging Bull.”

Speaking of “Raging Bull,” one of the greatest and most beautifully photographed films ever made, Egan actually says it is “quite simply across-the-board bad filmmaking, afflicted by preposterously exaggerated boxing action, an atmosphere-flattening lack of a soundtrack, agonisingly repetitive dialogue, endless and tedious confrontationalism and irritatingly pointless black-and-white stock.”

As for Egan’s complaint that Scorsese has “lazily” settled on the mafia genre. What?! I’ve counted a total of FIVE mob-related movies that Scorsese has directed these last 50 years. If anything, Scorsese has masterfully genre-hopped in his career (Horror, Historical, Biblical, Comedy, Musical).

Egan goes on to complain about “The Irishman” as Scorsese using “the same actors over and over: seeing Robert De Niro, Joe Pesci and Harvey Keitel in a Scorsese mobster movie for the umpteenth time.”

This is where Egan’s credibility gets thrown out of the window. When “The Irishman” came out, Scorsese hadn’t worked with DeNiro/Pesci in almost three decades. Keitel hadn’t been in a Scorsese picture since 1988’s “The Last Temptation of Christ.”

Suffice to say, reading Egan’s piece was akin to nails on a chalkboard. It’s such a preposterous essay that I wondered at times if he was just baiting us, if he was trolling the masses into believing that the greatest American filmmaker of the last 40-odd years was convoluted.

← Rumor: Chris Rock Has Finally Accepted to Host the Oscars?First Image of Adam Driver as Enzo Ferrari in Michael Mann’s ‘Ferrari’ →

FOLLOW US!


Trending

Featured
IMG_4571.jpg
David Fincher & Brad Pitt Reunite for ‘The Continuing Adventures of Cliff Booth' + Plot Details
IMG_4549.png
Warners Bros. Chief Admits Missteps on ‘Joker: Folie à Deux’: “We Misread the Room”
IMG_4541.jpg
Scorsese’s Next Film? Hawaiian Mob Epic With Dwayne Johnson Eyes 2026 Shoot
Capture.png
Jim Caviezel to be De-Aged in ‘The Resurrection of the Christ'
IMG_4465.png
Harmony Korine Says Hollywood Struggling Because “Movies Suck Today”

Critics Polls

Featured
Capture.PNG
Critics Poll: ‘Vertigo’ Named Best Film of the 1950s, Over 120 Participants
B16BAC21-5652-44F6-9E83-A1A5C5DF61D7.jpeg
Critics Poll: Kubrick’s ‘2001: A Space Odyssey’ Tops Our 1960s Critics Poll
Capture.PNG
Critics Poll: ‘The Godfather’ Named Best Movie of the 1970s
public.jpeg
Critics Poll: ‘Do the Right Thing' Named Best Movie of the 1980s
Critics Poll: ‘Mulholland Drive' Named Best Film of the 2000s
g4.jpg
Critics' Poll: ‘Goodfellas' Named Best Movie of the 1990s
Critics Poll: ‘Mad Max: Fury Road' Named Best Movie of the 2010s
World of Reel tagline.PNG
 

Content

Contribute

Hire me

 

Support

Advertise

Donate

 

About

Team

Contact

Privacy Policy

Site designed by Jordan Ruimy © 2023